Courthouse steps representing a New York personal injury lawsuit against a convicted offender

Suing a Criminal for Personal Injury in New York

Personal Injuries Resulting From Criminal Acts in New York

Criminal conduct can leave a person with serious physical injuries, long recoveries, and financial strain that continues well after the incident. A person injured by another's criminal acts, or the family or representative of that person, may have grounds to seek compensation through a personal injury lawsuit. That civil case is separate from any criminal prosecution and is brought to recover for the harm the injured person suffered.

CPLR 213-b — Suing a Criminal for Personal Injury

CPLR § 213-b allows a crime victim, or the representative of a crime victim as defined in Executive Law § 621(6), to sue a defendant who was convicted of the crime at issue, under extended filing periods. A statute of limitations is the deadline for starting a lawsuit, and this provision can give qualifying claimants more time than the ordinary deadlines would allow.

Two separate periods apply, and each is measured from a different event. For a defendant convicted of the crime that is the subject of the action, the lawsuit may be commenced within seven years of the date of the crime. For a defendant convicted of a “specified crime” as defined in Executive Law § 632-a(1)(e), the lawsuit may be commenced within ten years of the date of the conviction.

Both periods depend on a conviction for the underlying crime. They do not automatically apply to every physical injury caused by criminal conduct, and whether an offense counts as a specified crime must be confirmed against the conviction and the statutory definition.

Read the Full Text of CPLR 213-b

§ 213-b. Action by a victim of a criminal offense. Notwithstanding any other limitation set forth in this article or in article five of the estates, powers and trusts law, an action by a crime victim, or the representative of a crime victim, as defined in subdivision six of section six hundred twenty-one of the executive law, may be commenced to recover damages from a defendant: (1) convicted of a crime which is the subject of such action, for any injury or loss resulting therefrom within seven years of the date of the crime or (2) convicted of a specified crime as defined in paragraph (e) of subdivision one of section six hundred thirty-two-a of the executive law which is the subject of such action for any injury or loss resulting therefrom within ten years of the date the defendant was convicted of such specified crime.

Types of Criminal Acts That May Give Rise to Personal Injury Claims

Many kinds of criminal conduct cause bodily harm. Common examples include assaults, robberies, and other offenses in which a person is attacked or hurt. These incidents can result in fractures, head injuries, stab or gunshot wounds, and lasting physical and emotional effects.

The name of an offense does not decide the outcome. A qualifying conviction matters for the special filing periods, but whether a personal injury claim can be established depends on the particular facts, the evidence, and the harm that resulted. A conviction does not by itself establish every element of a civil claim.

Compensation Available to Victims Injured by Criminal Acts

Damages in a personal injury lawsuit may include medical expenses, lost wages, the cost of future medical care, pain and suffering, and permanent disability, where the injuries and the evidence support them. These categories are meant to account for both the financial losses and the personal toll of the injury.

The type and amount of recovery depend on the nature of the injuries, how they affect daily life and work, and the circumstances of the case. No outcome can be assumed in advance.

Insurance Coverage and Collecting Compensation From Convicted Offenders

Winning a judgment does not necessarily mean the full amount can be collected. Insurance liability policies may exclude intentional criminal conduct, though coverage depends on the policy's terms and the circumstances, and it should not be assumed either way. A convicted offender may also have limited assets or income, which can make collection slow or difficult.

In some cases, another party may bear independent responsibility for the injury, such as a property owner, employer, or security company. Any such claim needs its own factual basis, and § 213-b does not extend the deadline for claims against parties who were not convicted of the underlying crime. Claims against public entities or those governed by specialized limitation periods call for a separate deadline analysis.

New York Personal Injury Lawyer for Victims of Criminal Acts

The attorneys at Sternberg Injury Law Firm can evaluate a bodily-injury claim arising from criminal conduct, review the offender's conviction, assess the applicable deadlines, and investigate potential sources of recovery. Records fade and deadlines pass, so prompt review matters. Consultations at our firm are always complimentary. The Sternberg Injury Law Firm handles injury cases on a contingency fee basis, so no attorney's fee is owed unless compensation is recovered. You can reach us by phone call, text message, email, or website submission at any convenient time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sometimes, yes. A civil personal injury claim can sometimes proceed without a criminal conviction, because a lawsuit and a prosecution are separate proceedings and have different standards of proof. The special extended filing periods discussed on this page, however, depend on a qualifying conviction. Other causes of action and other deadlines may apply, so the situation should be reviewed promptly.

Possibly. An injured person's own conduct may affect whether a claim is available and how it turns out, but the analysis depends on the facts and on the type of wrongdoing that is alleged. Intentional misconduct is not treated the same way as carelessness. An individual evaluation is the only reliable way to understand how a particular altercation would be viewed.

Possibly. A person physically injured during criminal conduct directed at someone else may still have a civil claim, depending on the offender's conduct and the circumstances of the injury. The person injured and the intended target do not always have to be the same. Whether special statutory provisions apply to a bystander is a question that requires legal review.